Leaders in the Bay

Bay Area leaders shaping the future — featured by Akilis World.

Melanie Bagby

Candidate for Sonoma County Supervisor, District 4

·By: Mbaire

Melanie Bagby

Photo Credit: Melanie Bagby

"We can't lose sight of the person who can't afford groceries, bus fare, or to fix their car. They need help now, not just promises..."

Melanie Bagby didn't set out to become a politician. Her journey began when friends from her book club persuaded her to attend a Cloverdale City Council meeting. What started as an interest in local planning became more than 15 years of public service, including two terms on the City Council and a tenure as mayor. A Sonoma County native and longtime technology professional, Bagby is now running for District 4 Supervisor against former Santa Rosa Mayor and Police Chief Tom Schwedhelm. Her campaign draws on years of work in transportation, land use, clean energy, and regional government. Ahead of the November 3 election, Bagby spoke with Akilis World about her unconventional path into politics, the decisions that tested her leadership, the county's affordability crisis, and what she would do differently.

Who is Melanie Bagby when the cameras are off?

Sonoma County is my home. I grew up in northern Santa Rosa, went away to college in Southern California, and worked in Silicon Valley and San Francisco before my husband and I decided we wanted to be closer to family. We've lived in Cloverdale for 26 years, and I never really intended to get into politics. It was actually my girlfriends from the book club who got me started. They were involved in what was happening in Cloverdale and kept encouraging me to come to City Council meetings. At the time, the city was updating its general plan and developing its urban growth boundary, and once I understood what was at stake, I found myself really passionate about it.

You've served Sonoma County for over 15 years. Why run for Supervisor now?

With two open seats on the Board of Supervisors, this is a rare opportunity to bring northern Sonoma County's perspective to the table. I've spent years serving communities from Santa Rosa to Cloverdale, and I understand their different challenges. I've gained valuable experience through public service, and I feel a responsibility to put that experience to work for the county.

What's the hardest decision you've made as a leader?

A couple come to mind. One was approving Flock cameras in Cloverdale. I'm a technologist, and I understand the value of that technology, particularly for a community like ours along the Highway 101 corridor. But I'm also someone who believes technology needs safeguards, and I spent a lot of time reading the agreements and talking with our police chief before making that decision. The other challenge was dealing with Cloverdale's structural budget deficit. When you're working with limited money, you have to make difficult decisions about what matters most to your community. I'm actually glad I had that experience because the county government faces serious financial pressures, and I've learned how important it is for a budget to reflect your values.

You're facing former Santa Rosa Mayor and Police Chief Tom Schwedhelm. What sets you apart?

Tom and I served on our respective city councils at the same time, and we're fundamentally different people. He comes from a career in law enforcement, while I come from information technology. I got involved in government because I cared about the environment, the economy, and things as basic as making sure children had sidewalks and safe routes to school. Over the years, I've worked extensively on transportation, land use, clean energy, and regional policy through organizations like Sonoma Clean Power, the Sonoma County Transportation Authority, and the League of California Cities. What I've really come to understand is that these aren't simply planning or infrastructure issues. They're questions of access, opportunity, and equality. That's the perspective I would bring to the Board of Supervisors, along with the experience of working across different levels of government.

Politics has become increasingly polarized. How do you represent people who disagree with you?

You learn a lot serving on a small-town city council. People stop you at the grocery store and ask why you're spending money on one thing when their roads still need paving. You have to be accessible and willing to listen, even when people disagree with you. I've learned that when someone is angry, it's important to ask what's really behind that frustration. I recently had a couple confront me about an issue at a local school, but once we started talking, it became a meaningful conversation rather than an argument. It doesn't always work, of course. Some people are just going to be angry, and you have to know how to bring the temperature down. I believe that listening, keeping an open mind, and having honest discussions can lead to better decisions than the ones you originally had in mind.
Photo Credit: Melanie Bagby

Sonoma County is becoming increasingly unaffordable. How do you help working families stay?

We have to be realistic about what it costs to live in Sonoma County. The economic data I've seen suggests people need around $34 an hour to cover their expenses, and that's a huge challenge for working families. We need to move toward living wages without placing an unfair burden on small businesses. The county government can lead by example. Why are we contracting out jobs when we could be training students from Santa Rosa Junior College and Sonoma State, creating good-paying careers, and keeping that money circulating in our communities? There's also tremendous opportunity in agriculture. As some wineries take vineyards out of production, we could support small farmers and strengthen our local food economy. I'd also like to revisit plans for a USDA-inspected slaughterhouse on the North Coast to make it easier for local livestock producers to do business.

With limited resources, how do you balance housing, economic growth, and environmental protection?

I think we need to start with a pretty basic principle: public land should be used for public benefit. When the government already owns land, why would we sell it off when we could retain ownership and work with nonprofit developers to build affordable housing? Land prices are one of the biggest barriers to housing in Sonoma County, and taxpayers have already made an investment in those properties. I'm concerned about arrangements that are described as public-private partnerships but end up giving developers public assets without ensuring enough lasting benefit for the community. We've spent years protecting our urban growth boundaries and open spaces, and those things matter. But I think we can preserve what makes Sonoma County special while being much smarter about how we use public resources to address housing and economic needs.
photo credit: Carlos Calito

The Fair Political Practices Commission imposed a $9,000 penalty for two conflict-of-interest violations. What went wrong?

I'm glad you asked, because I think people should understand what happened. The first incident was in 2020 at Sonoma Clean Power. A contract involving a client of my IT company came through the consent calendar, and I missed it. I'd recused myself from earlier votes involving that client, but I failed to catch that particular item. The second happened in 2023 on the Cloverdale City Council, when I voted to approve a contract with Ross Recreation Equipment, another client of my company. That should have been flagged, and I should have recused myself, but I missed it. Ultimately, both decisions were my responsibility, and I take full responsibility for those mistakes. I considered the legal costs of contesting the matter and decided to accept the penalty. The experience taught me the importance of stronger safeguards, so if elected, I'd make sure every meeting packet and revision is reviewed for potential conflicts. I made two human errors in 15 years of public service, and I take full responsibility.

If elected, what will be your priorities in the first year?

If you'd asked me that when I first started running, I probably would have given you a different answer because circumstances have changed, and the county is facing serious financial challenges. First, we have to protect essential services and navigate the county budget responsibly. That means making difficult decisions while keeping the needs of vulnerable residents in mind. Second, I want to strengthen civilian oversight of the Sonoma County Sheriff's Office. I believe the oversight system needs the resources to operate effectively, and residents should have the same expectation of accountability whether their community is served by a city police department or the sheriff. And third, I want to keep moving forward on transportation, clean energy, housing, and affordability. Those issues are connected, and they're not going away.
Photo Credit: Melanie Bagby

What keeps you up at night about Sonoma County's future?

It's funny because people keep asking whether I'm nervous and how I'm sleeping during such a competitive campaign. I'm actually sleeping great! I've learned that when you're dealing with difficult situations or people who disagree with you, it's better to respond than react. That helps me stay grounded. Of course, I think about how divided we've become and how many people are struggling with everyday expenses. But I also look around and see real progress. SMART has reached Windsor, there are plans to extend service farther north, we're connecting bike paths, and projects like Petaluma River Park are transforming public spaces. I remember what some of these places looked like years ago, and it's encouraging to see what's possible when communities invest in their future. Additionally, we can't lose sight of the person who can't afford groceries, bus fare, or to fix their car. They need help now, not just promises about what things might look like in ten years.